|
Timon of Athens
·III ii 30 ·
Prose
1st Stranger First Stranger. Why, this is the world's soul; and just of the same piece Is every flatterer's spirit. Who can call him His friend that dips in the same dish? for, in My knowing, Timon has been this lord's father, And kept his credit with his purse, Supported his estate; nay, Timon's money Has paid his men their wages: he ne'er drinks, But Timon's silver treads upon his lip; And yet—O, see the monstrousness of man When he looks out in an ungrateful shape!— He does deny him, in respect of his, What charitable men afford to beggars. First Stranger. For mine own part, I never tasted Timon in my life, Nor came any of his bounties over me, To mark me for his friend; yet, I protest, For his right noble mind, illustrious virtue And honourable carriage, Had his necessity made use of me, I would have put my wealth into donation, And the best half should have return'd to him, So much I love his heart: but, I perceive, Men must learn now with pity to dispense; For policy sits above conscience. |
Original: Why, this is the world’s soul; and just of the same piece
Modern: This is exactly how the world works; it’s all cut from the same cloth
Original: Is every flatterer’s spirit. Who can call him
Modern: Every fake friend acts this way. How can anyone call someone
Original: His friend that dips in the same dish? for, in
Modern: A true friend when they eat at the same table? Because, from what
Original: My knowing, Timon has been this lord’s father,
Modern: I know, Timon has been like a father to this lord,
Original: And kept his credit with his purse,
Modern: And protected his reputation with his own money,
Original: Supported his estate; nay, Timon’s money
Modern: Kept up his property; in fact, Timon’s money
Original: Has paid his men their wages: he ne’er drinks,
Modern: Has paid his servants their salaries: he never drinks anything,
Original: But Timon’s silver treads upon his lip;
Modern: Without Timon’s money paying for it;
Original: And yet—O, see the monstrousness of man
Modern: And yet—oh, look at how terrible people can be
Original: When he looks out in an ungrateful shape!—
Modern: When they show their ungrateful nature!—
Original: He does deny him, in respect of his,
Modern: He refuses to give Timon, compared to his own wealth,
Original: What charitable men afford to beggars.
Modern: What kind people would give to beggars.
Original: For mine own part,
Modern: As for myself,
Original: I never tasted Timon in my life,
Modern: I never received any favors from Timon in my life,
Original: Nor came any of his bounties over me,
Modern: Nor did any of his generosity come my way,
Original: To mark me for his friend; yet, I protest,
Modern: To make me one of his friends; but still, I swear,
Original: For his right noble mind, illustrious virtue
Modern: Because of his truly noble character, his outstanding virtue
Original: And honourable carriage,
Modern: And honorable behavior,
Original: Had his necessity made use of me,
Modern: If he had ever needed my help,
Original: I would have put my wealth into donation,
Modern: I would have given away my wealth as a gift,
Original: And the best half should have return’d to him,
Modern: And the better half would have gone to him,
Original: So much I love his heart: but, I perceive,
Modern: That’s how much I admire his character: but, I can see,
Original: Men must learn now with pity to dispense;
Modern: People must now learn to be stingy with their compassion;
Original: For policy sits above conscience.
Modern: Because selfish schemes are more important than doing what’s right.
In Act III, Scene ii of “Timon of Athens,” Lucius encounters a Stranger and three Servants of Timon who have come seeking payment of debts owed by their generous master. The Servants explain that Timon, once wealthy and extraordinarily liberal with his gifts, now finds himself in severe financial distress and unable to pay his creditors. They describe how Timon’s steward has sent them out to collect debts from those who previously benefited from Timon’s generosity, but they have met with refusal and disappointment from former recipients of his bounty.
Lucius expresses shock and dismay upon learning of Timon’s financial ruin, claiming he would have gladly helped had he known of the situation earlier. However, when the Servants directly ask him for assistance, Lucius makes excuses about his own financial constraints and the unfortunate timing of their request. The Stranger observes this exchange with growing disgust at Lucius’s hypocrisy, noting how quickly Lucius shifts from expressions of concern to actual refusal to help. After Lucius departs, the Stranger delivers a soliloquy condemning the ingratitude and selfishness of those who benefited from Timon’s generosity but now abandon him in his time of need.
Timon of Athens tells the story of a wealthy Athenian nobleman whose excessive generosity leads to his downfall. In the first half of the play, Timon lavishes gifts, throws extravagant banquets, and freely lends money to anyone who asks, despite warnings from his loyal steward Flavius about his dwindling finances. Timon dismisses these concerns, believing his generosity will be repaid by the loyalty of his many friends. However, his creditors eventually come calling, and Timon discovers he has no money left to pay his debts.
When Timon’s financial ruin becomes apparent, he sends servants to ask his former friends and beneficiaries for loans to help him through his crisis. One by one, they all refuse him with various excuses - Lucilius claims his money is tied up in investments, Lucullus pretends not to be home, and Sempronius feels insulted that Timon didn’t ask him first. Faced with this universal rejection, Timon invites all his false friends to one final feast, where he serves them warm water and stones, then curses them and banishes himself from Athens.
Timon retreats to a cave in the wilderness outside Athens, where he becomes a misanthropic hermit, railing against humanity and civilization. While digging for roots to eat, he discovers gold in the earth. Various visitors come to see him in his exile, including the loyal Flavius, the philosopher Apemantus (who had always criticized Timon’s generosity), thieves seeking the gold, and the exiled general Alcibiades who is marching against Athens. Timon gives away the gold freely but refuses all attempts at reconciliation or friendship. The play ends with news of Timon’s death reaching Athens, where Alcibiades has successfully taken the city and promises to restore order and justice.