Light Mode

Shakespeare's Monologues



Constance — “Thou monstrous injurer of heaven and earth!” — King John, Act 2, Scene 1, line 182



King John Play summary   ·II i 182Scene summary  · Verse
Constance

Constance: Thou monstrous injurer of heaven and earth!
Call not me slanderer; thou and thine usurp
The dominations, royalties and rights
Of this oppressed boy: this is thy eld'st son's son,
Infortunate in nothing but in thee:
Thy sins are visited in this poor child;
The canon of the law is laid on him,
Being but the second generation
Removed from thy sin-conceiving womb.

King John: Bedlam, have done.

Constance: I have but this to say,
That he is not only plagued for her sin,
But God hath made her sin and her the plague
On this removed issue, plague for her
And with her plague; her sin his injury,
Her injury the beadle to her sin,
All punish'd in the person of this child,
And all for her; a plague upon her!
Modern paraphrasing 👆 Click for a double-spaced PDF of this monologue

Original: Thou monstrous injurer of heaven and earth!
Modern: You horrible person who wrongs both heaven and earth!

Original: Call not me slanderer; thou and thine usurp
Modern: Don’t call me a liar; you and your family are stealing

Original: The dominations, royalties and rights
Modern: The power, royal titles, and legal claims

Original: Of this oppressed boy: this is thy eld’st son’s son,
Modern: That belong to this mistreated boy: this is your eldest son’s son,

Original: Infortunate in nothing but in thee:
Modern: Unlucky in nothing except having you as his grandmother:

Original: Thy sins are visited in this poor child;
Modern: Your sins are being punished through this poor child;

Original: The canon of the law is laid on him,
Modern: The weight of God’s law has fallen on him,

Original: Being but the second generation
Modern: Even though he’s only the second generation

Original: Removed from thy sin-conceiving womb.
Modern: Born after your sinful body gave birth.

Original: I have but this to say,
Modern: I have only this to say,

Original: That he is not only plagued for her sin,
Modern: That he’s not only being punished for her sin,

Original: But God hath made her sin and her the plague
Modern: But God has made both her sin and herself into the punishment

Original: On this removed issue, plague for her
Modern: Inflicted on this distant descendant, a plague because of her

Original: And with her plague; her sin his injury,
Modern: And along with her as the plague; her sin causes his suffering,

Original: Her injury the beadle to her sin,
Modern: Her wrongdoing acts as the officer enforcing punishment for her sin,

Original: All punish’d in the person of this child,
Modern: Everything being punished in this child’s life,

Original: And all for her; a plague upon her!
Modern: And all because of her; may she be cursed!

In Act II, Scene 1 of “King John,” the action takes place before the walls of Angiers, where the forces of King John of England and King Philip of France have both arrived to claim the city. The scene opens with representatives from both sides attempting to persuade the citizens of Angiers to recognize their respective monarchs’ authority. John claims the throne through his own right as Richard I’s brother, while Philip argues on behalf of Arthur, Duke of Brittany, the son of John’s deceased older brother Geoffrey, asserting that Arthur has the stronger hereditary claim. The citizens of Angiers refuse to choose between the two kings until they can determine who has the legitimate right to rule England.

The conflict escalates as both armies prepare for battle, with various lords and nobles exchanging threats and declarations of loyalty to their respective kings. Before the battle commences, the Bastard (Philip Faulconbridge) delivers spirited commentary on the situation, and both sides engage in formal challenges. The scene includes a proposal of marriage between Lewis, the Dauphin of France, and Blanche of Spain, John’s niece, as a potential solution to the conflict. This marriage proposal, combined with territorial concessions from John, leads to a political resolution where Philip abandons Arthur’s cause in exchange for the advantageous match and lands, leaving Arthur and his mother Constance betrayed by their former ally.

King John opens with King Philip of France supporting Arthur, the young son of John’s deceased brother Geoffrey, as the rightful heir to the English throne. John’s mother, Queen Eleanor, and the French court engage in heated disputes over legitimacy. Meanwhile, the Bastard (Philip Faulconbridge), illegitimate son of Richard the Lionheart, joins John’s cause after being legitimized. War breaks out between England and France, with the strategic town of Angiers caught between the two armies.

The conflict temporarily resolves when John’s niece Blanche marries the French Dauphin Lewis, uniting the two kingdoms. However, Cardinal Pandulph arrives from Rome and excommunicates John for refusing to accept Stephen Langton as Archbishop of Canterbury. The Cardinal persuades France to break the peace and resume war against the excommunicated English king. In the ensuing battle, Arthur is captured by John’s forces.

John orders Hubert to kill the young Arthur, but Hubert cannot bring himself to murder the child and instead hides him. When Arthur later dies attempting to escape from his prison tower, the English nobles believe John has murdered him and defect to join the invading French forces led by the Dauphin. As John faces rebellion from within and invasion from without, he submits to the Pope’s authority to regain legitimacy. However, he falls ill and is poisoned by a monk at Swinstead Abbey.

The Bastard rallies the remaining English forces and discovers that the French nobles plan to kill their English allies after victory. This intelligence helps reconcile the English lords to their king. John dies, and his young son Henry is crowned King Henry III. The Dauphin withdraws his forces, and Cardinal Pandulph negotiates peace. The play concludes with the Bastard delivering a patriotic speech about England’s strength when united against foreign threats.